"'I will put my question in another form. Do you remember witnessing Mr. Thomas Ossington's attachment of his signature to a certain document on the 22nd of October, 1892?'
"I had noticed that Mr. Nicholls and he had exchanged glances when I first put my query. Now he looked at his principal evidently in search of guidance.
"'Shall I answer this gentleman's question, sir?'
"'Certainly. Give him all the information you can.'
"This Mr. Hurley proceeded to do, with the utmost clearness.
"'I do remember the 22nd of October, 1892, and the whole of the circumstances. I chanced to meet Mr. Ossington in Holborn as I was leaving the office. He asked me if I would dine with him in his house at Wandsworth. I went with him to dinner there and then. After dinner he asked me if I would witness his signature. I expressed my willingness. I witnessed it.'
"'Were you acquainted with the nature of the document he was signing?'
"'I was not. I have often wondered what it was, especially in the light of after events. The document, which was on a sheet of blue foolscap, had evidently been prepared before my arrival: Mr. Ossington, covering the writing with a piece of blotting-paper, signed it, in the middle of the page, directly underneath, while I affixed my signature, as witness, on the left-hand side.'
"'Was there another witness?'
"'There was, the servant girl.'
"'What was her name?'
"'I never heard it. I only know that he called her Louisa. I think I should recognise her if I saw her again. She was a red-faced, light-haired, strapping wench, about eighteen years of age.'
"'Should you recognise Ossington's signature-and your own-and the document to which they were attached?'
"'Most decidedly; under any circumstances, at any time.'
"I thanked him for his frankness, and rose to go. Nicholls stopped me.
"'One moment,' he said. 'Hurley informed us, at the time, of what he has just now told you, and, like him, we have frequently wondered what was the nature of the document he witnessed. As you are evidently aware that such a paper existed once upon a time, you are probably acquainted with its present whereabouts?'
"'I am. It will be produced in due course. When, I promise you, you will see as curious a document as is to be found upon the records.'
"Both Nicholls and Hurley endeavoured to induce me to be more definite. But I was not to be persuaded. Thanking them for the information they had given me, I came away."
CHAPTER XIII
AN INTERRUPTED TREASURE HUNT
"Well," inquired Martyn, when Graham? had finished, "what is the situation now?"
"First of all," struck in Madge, "how about the will?"
"As regards the will, I do not hesitate to say that it is as sound and valid a declaration of the testator's wishes as has been admitted to probate-Mr. Hurley's testimony removes all doubt upon that point. A man has a right to do what he will with his own-and that is all Mr. Ossington has done."
"How does it effect our right of search?"
"That is another question. The will gives neither you nor any one else a title for the destruction of property. It simply conveys to the finder the possession of certain things which are not specifically mentioned. But it authorises no one to look for those things, still less to do damage while looking."
"Then is our search barred? Aren't we to look at all?"
"I don't say that. My advice is to put the legal aspect aside, and to regard the common-sense one only. The will says that certain things, when found, are to become the property of the finder, and this house with them. You have reason to believe that those things are concealed within this house. Then it is for you to consider whether it is worth your while to run the risk of becoming responsible for any damage you may do in case of your failure to find those things. My opinion is, that it is worth your while to run that risk-that it is worth any one's while to run that risk."
Madge stood up, with resolute lips, and sparkling eyes. She struck her hand upon the table.
"I'm sure it is! I know it is!"
Bruce Graham also rose.
"I am willing to share the risk if it is shareable-or to assume the whole of it, for the matter of that. I incline strongly to your belief, Miss Brodie, that there is something hidden well worth the finding, and that its hiding-place is within the walls of Clover Cottage."
Jack Martyn hammered his fist upon the table.
"Hear, hear! – bravo! – spoken like a man! 'Pon my word, I'm beginning to think that there is something in it after all. A conviction is creeping over me, slowly but surely, that in less time than no time I shall be filling my pockets with the contents of Aladdin's Cave-and as there is only a bent sixpence and two bad pennies in them at present, there's plenty of room for more."
"The point is," said Ella, "where are you going to begin to look?"
"I am going to do what Mr. Nicholls wanted to do," declared Madge-"tear the house to pieces."
"But, my dear, even if you set about the business in that drastic fashion, you'll require method. How are you going to begin to take the house to pieces-by taking the slates off the roof, and the chimney-pots down?"
"And by taking the windows out of their frames, and the doors off their hinges, and displaying the grates in the front garden! George! you'll be improving the property with a vengeance if you do."
"I propose to do nothing so absurd. I simply wish you to understand that before I give up the search the house will literally have been torn to pieces-though I assure you, Ella, that I do not intend to begin by taking off either the slates or the chimney-pots."
"Have you been able to make anything more of the writing which was left behind by your burglarious visitor?"
The inquiry came from Graham. Madge shook her head.
"Let me try my hand at it," cried Jack. "I have brains-I place them at your service. It is true I never have been able to solve a puzzle from my very earliest hours, but that is no reason why I should not begin by solving this."
The scrap of paper was given him. He spread it out on the table in front of him. Leaning his head upon his hands, he stared at it, the expression on his face scarcely promising a prompt elucidation.
"The first part is simple, extremely simple. Especially after Mr. Graham's last night's lucid exposition. Otherwise I should have described it as recondite. But the second part's a howler; yes, a howler! 'Right-cat-dog-cat-dog-cat-dog-cat-dog-left eye- push!' The conjunction is surprising. I can only remark that if that assorted collection of animals is bottled up somewhere in this house all together, that alone would be a find worth coming upon. There will be some lively moments when you let the collection out."
"Did you mention anything to Mr. Nicholls about the paper?" asked Madge of Graham.
"Not a syllable. I gathered from what he said that the house was done up before it was let-papered, painted, and so on, and that therefore any former landmarks to which it might have been alluding have probably disappeared."
"That's what I think, and that's what I mean by saying we shall have to pull the house to pieces."
"Even if that is the case, as Miss Duncan puts it, where are you going to begin? You must remember that you will have to continue living in the house while it is being dismantled, and that you must spare yourselves as much discomfort as possible."
"It seems that you have to begin by pushing the left eye," said Jack, who still was studying the paper. "Though whether it is the left eye of the entire assorted collection is not quite clear. If that is the case, and that remarkable optic has to be pushed with any degree of vigour, I can only say that I shall take up a position in the centre of the road till the proceedings are concluded."
"Why not commence," asked Madge, "with a thorough examination of the room which we're now in?"
"You yourself," said Ella, "admitted last night that it was hardly likely that the treasure would be hidden in the same room which contained the will."