Astrology and Science

Astrology and Science
Dimitry Referee

Margarita Referee

How do astrology and science interact in the 21st century? Are neural networks and artificial intelligence applicable in astrology? How was astrology successfully tested at the Russian Academy of Sciences? Why is the problem of the demarcation of astrology and science a pseudo-problem created by pseudo-skeptics? Were Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo and Ptolemy against astrology? Find the answers to these and other questions about the relationship between astrology and science in this book.

Margarita Referee, Dimitry Referee

Astrology and Science

Introduction

Before the onset of the third millennium, there was a lot of talk about the end of times and the change of eras. Someone filmed disaster films, someone frightened people with decryptions of prophecies about the end of the world, someone encouraged others not to throw hysteria, someone enjoyed postmodernism, revealed at the turn of the century in all its glory.

Meanwhile, the musicians recorded songs and albums, the titles of which featured the exciting and mysterious word millennium. A new thousand was to appear on the counter of the years that have passed since the birth of Christ. The atmosphere of expectation of the new millennium has developed on the basis of ideas about the coming of the Age of Aquarius (New Age). It was mystical, but at the same time, it was ironic in a postmodern way. This mood was expressed by the British singer Robbie Williams in a song called “Millennium”, released in 1998, just at the peak of the wave of millennial anticipation.

Williams sang about his cynical friends, about life “for liposuction,” about making money from the very cradle. In a perky video for this song, Williams, with a grin, encroached on the “holy of holies”: he parodied the great hero-spy of all Great Britain – James Bond.

But what does this have to do with astrology, you ask? It’s all about the chorus repeating from the very beginning of the song:

We’ve got stars directing our fate

And we’re praying it’s not too late

Millennium…

Robbie Williams has clearly caught the zeitgeist. 20 years after the song was released, articles with headlines like “Why Do So Many Millennials Believe in Horoscopes?” (The Independent, 02/19/2017) or “Why Are Millennials So Into Astrology?” (The Atlantic, 01/16/2018) began to appear in serious publications, in which the authors asked how it happened that “58 percent of 18–24-year-old Americans believe astrology is scientific”.

Millennials are those who were born after 1981, that is, relatively speaking, those who met the beginning of the third millennium at a young age and, presumably, to the sound of a song by Robbie Williams, singing about how the stars rule our destinies.

“The study also revealed that skepticism of astrology is decreasing, and indeed you don’t have to look far online to find the strong community of young, cool, perfectly normal people who obsess over their zodiac signs”.

If you look not only at millennials, then the attitude towards astrology in the countries of the Western world (in the East it is traditionally positive) at the beginning of the 21st century was as follows:[1 - Рефери, МиД (September 15, 2013). “Верит ли в астрологию человек 21 века?” [Does a person of the 21st century believe in astrology?]. Альфа Любви. Retrieved November 28, 2021. URL=http://midref.ru/blog/21-century-man-believes-in-astrology]

– According to a 2008 study, 22% of Britons believe in astrology and 15% believe in fortune-telling or Tarot. These results, in comparison with the results of the 1951 poll, were "especially striking", because, in 1951, only 7% of the respondents said that they believe in prediction by cards and 6% – by stars.[2 - “Most people believe in life after death, study finds”. The Telegraph. April 13, 2009. Retrieved November 28, 2021. URL=http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/religion/5144766/Most-people-believe-in-life-after-death-study-finds.html]

– According to the US National Science Foundation, at least a quarter of the US population in 2004 believed in astrology. 32% of Americans believed that "some numbers are particularly lucky for some people."[3 - "Science and Technology: Public Attitudes and Understandingy”. Science and engineering indicators 2004. Retrieved November 28, 2021. URL=http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/seind04/c7/c7s2.htm]

– In Europe, belief in astrology is more widespread than in the United States. According to the 2001 European Commission, 53% of Europeans believe that astrology is “rather scientific”. At the same time, only 42% consider economics to be scientific, 65% – psychology, 33% – history. 46% of Europeans believe that "some numbers are particularly lucky for some people."[4 - Ibid.]

– A 2009 survey found that nearly half of Australians surveyed believe in supernatural powers such as extrasensory perception, and 41% of Australians believe in astrology.[5 - "We believe in God, UFOs and astrology”. Herald Sun. December 19, 2009. Retrieved November 28, 2021. URL=https://amp.news.com.au/national/we-believe-in-god-ufos-and-astrology/news-story/76c2ef01bf01b0ac5b300df2522ccd07]

– According to a survey carried out by the Levada Center in 2013, 28% of Russians believe in astrological predictions. More than half of Russians (52%) believe in omens, and 43% believe in prophetic dreams.[6 - “Вера россиян в приметы, вещие сны и астрологию снижается – опрос" [Russians' faith in omens, prophetic dreams and astrology is declining – survey]. Интерфакс. March 17, 2013. Retrieved November 28, 2021. URL=https://www.interfax.ru/russia/295934]

***

How did it happen that despite scientific progress, including space flights, and the fact that worried scientists with great zeal and PR noise disown astrology and blaspheme it, the ancient doctrine of the influence of planets and stars on earthly life is winning its place in the minds of people again?

Some scientific skeptics tend to see in the modern craze for astrology a "boom of obscurantism" characteristic of "crisis moments of social development, for periods of socio-cultural timelessness."[7 - Рабинович, В. Л. “Астрология” [Astrology]. Энциклопедия эпистемологии и философии науки [Encyclopedia of Epistemology and Philosophy of Science]. «Канон"1"» РООИ «Реабилитация», 2009, pp.76-77.] However, those scientists who are more conscientious tend to look critically not at astrology, but science. Thus, researcher Paul Woolley, commenting on the results of a British survey on attitudes towards astrology, noted that "the enlightenment optimism in the ability of science and reason to explain everything ended decades ago."[8 - "Most people believe in life after death, study finds”. The Telegraph. April 13, 2009. Retrieved November 28, 2021. URL=http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/religion/5144766/Most-people-believe-in-life-after-death-study-finds.html]

However, one should not exaggerate the possibilities of astrology. A good share of healthy skepticism should always be present, and not only in matters of astrology (where a lot of extraneous noise and very little academicism have accumulated over the millennia).

The authors of the Great Russian Encyclopedia say the following:[9 - Куртик, Г. Е.; Кобзев, А. И.; et al. “Астрология” [Astrology]. Большая российская энциклопедия. Том 2 [The Great Russian Encyclopedia. Volume 2]. Москва, 2005, pp.404-408.]

"Developed systems of astrology existed in ancient Mesopotamia, Greece, in the countries of Hellenistic culture (including Egypt), India, and China. In the Middle Ages, astrology was especially popular in the countries of Islam and Western Europe. Astrological teachings were closely related to magic and alchemy. Astrology was one of the sciences up to the Renaissance, but the achievements of modern science brought astrology beyond the limits of the scientific activity itself."

So where exactly have the achievements of science "brought astrology", and how are the relations between astrology and science developing in the third millennium? Let's try to figure it out.

Were Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo and Ptolemy against astrology?

References to ancient authorities in defense of astrology are very much disliked by some modern scientists who are very worried about the purity of science and are trying to retroactively “cleanse” the ancient thinkers, astronomers, and mathematicians of their interest in astrology. Most of the protests and indignation among the zealots of science are caused by the interest in astrology on the part of Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo, and even Claudius Ptolemy. Let's figure out whether the great minds of the past studied and practiced astrology or were against it.

Nicolaus Copernicus and Astrology

The Polish astronomer and mathematician Nicolaus Copernicus, who discovered the heliocentric system of the world, was born on February 19, 1473.

There is no doubt that Copernicus studied astrology at the University of Padua, where he studied medicine. But whether Copernicus practiced astrology is unknown.[10 - Rabin, Sheila (2005). “Copernicus”. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (summer 2005 edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.).] However, Professor Frank Robbins, who translated and commented on Ptolemy's Tetrabiblos, attributed Copernicus to the eminent astronomers of the Renaissance who "either practised astrology themselves or countenanced its practice."[11 - Ptolemy, Claudius (1964) [1940]. “Introduction”. Tetrabiblos. Loeb Classical Library edition, translated by F.E.Robbins PhD. London: William Heinemann. URL=https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Ptolemy/Tetrabiblos/Introduction*.html]

The main work of Copernicus ("On the Revolutions of the Celestial Spheres") was perceived by many contemporaries as an opportunity to improve the quality of astrological predictions due to a more accurate determination of the positions of the planets in the sky. It is also known that Copernicus dedicated his work to Pope Paul III, who highly appreciated astrology and promoted the astrologer Luca Gaurico, who twice predicted the election of the pope, to a cardinal.[12 - Sachiko Kusukawa (1999). “Copernicus's Book”. The Department of History and Philosophy of Science of the University of Cambridge. Retrieved November 28, 2021. URL=http://www.sites.hps.cam.ac.uk/starry/coperbooks.html]

The heliocentric model on the ninth page of Copernicus's work "On the Revolutions of the Celestial Spheres"

Copernicus, with his discovery of the heliocentric system, overturned the ancient ideas about the Cosmos and marked the beginning of a scientific revolution. However, this did not lead to a change in astrological rules. Astrological ideas remained the same, having withstood the "blow" from the emerging science.

It is noteworthy that Georg Rheticus, a student of Copernicus, who most of all contributed to the spread and recognition of the heliocentric model, was an active practitioner of astrology and considered the heliocentric theory useful for astrologers.[13 - Куталёв, Д. “Исторические гороскопы: Первый ученик Коперника” [Historical Horoscopes: The First Disciple of Copernicus]. ARGO. Retrieved November 28, 2021. URL=http://www.argo-school.ru/issledovaniya/istoricheskie_goroskopy/pervyj_uchenik_kopernika/pervyj_uchenik_kopernika/]

Nicolaus Copernicus with Hipparchus, Ptolemy, Galileo, Brahe, Kepler, Newton, Laplace

Galileo Galilei's Horoscope, Cast by Himself

Galileo Galilei, the great Italian mathematician, astronomer, and astrologer, practiced astrology throughout his entire or almost his entire career. For the 17th century, practicing astrology was common among educated people.[14 - Rutkin, H. D. “Galileo, Astrology, and the Scientific Revolution: Another Look”. Program in History & Philosophy of Science & Technology, Stanford University. Retrieved November 28, 2021. URL=http://web.stanford.edu/dept/HPST/colloquia0405.html] The zealots of science often try to ignore this fact from the biography of Galileo, for example, through the assertion that he built horoscopes solely for the sake of money and denied the possibility of forecasting.[15 - See, for example, Hübner, W. “The Culture of Astrology from Ancient to Renaissance”. A Companion to Astrology in the Renaissance. Brill, 2004, p.58.]

However, the claims that Galileo denied the predictive power of astrology do not agree well with how carefully and in detail he built his own horoscope and the horoscopes of his daughters, for which he hardly received any money.[16 - Kollerstrom, N. “Galileo’s Astrology”. Largo Campo di Filosofare Eurosymposium Galileo 2001. Ed Montesinos and Solis, 2001. pp.421-432. Retrieved November 28, 2021. URL=http://www.skyscript.co.uk/galast.html] Galileo's own horoscopes for February 16, 1564, 15:30, and 16:30 were published by the National Library of Florence in 1980.

The first interesting point in these horoscopes is the date of birth. Galileo's birthday is usually considered February 15 (according to the Julian calendar), but Galileo's horoscopes, which are "the sole source of evidence concerning his birthdate",[17 - Ibid.] indicate February 16.

The second feature of Galileo's horoscopes is that to the left of the charts, he wrote out the data required to calculate the primary directions, which are used to view the horoscope in dynamics and predict the course of life. This suggests that Galileo was quite serious about astrology and its predictive capabilities.

Galileo Galilei (1564—1642)

Johannes Kepler and the True Genealogy of Astrology

Kepler did not decry astrology but loved it.

It gave him the strength to know and be able to.

E.M.

Johannes Kepler, a scientific romantic, astrologer, and astronomer, one of the greatest learned men wrote in his book "Tertius Interveniens" ("Third-party Interventions", 1610)[18 - In this book, Kepler outlined his reaction to the dispute between the detractor and the defender of astrology, taking a third party. Hence the title of his work.] a paragraph that became one of his most famous quotes: